Small Business Subcontracting Plan requirements under FAR 52.219-9 are frequently seen in solicitations from the federal government. The underlying reason is to advance opportunities to small Challenging Far 52.219 9 Small Business Subcontracting Plan Requirementsbusinesses in larger contracts. This is an example of Congress’s efforts to provide more contracting vehicles to smaller companies.

FAR Subcontracting Plan requirements usually seek to provide additional opportunities to Small Disadvantaged Businesses (SDB), Woman-Owned Small Businesses (WOSB), VOSB, SDVOSB and each HUBZone small business concern.

Small Business Subcontracting Plan Requirements

 A common hurdle for bidders when developing Small Business Subcontracting Plan requirements is whether there are actual contractors that are available to do the work. Others fear that when they submit the requirement in their bid, whether the Agency could terminate them for failure to meet the subcontracting requirements.

Others fear that when they submit the requirement in their bid, whether the Agency could terminate them for failure to meet the subcontracting requirements.

These are valid concerns. However, Small Business Subcontracting Plans should be viewed as goals. Large businesses can run into problems when they do not in good faith try to meet those goals. Be aware that the SBA has issued new rules about FAR 52.219-9 subcontracting plan requirements.

Be Aware of Other Provisions Besides FAR 52.219-9

When challenging Small Business FAR Subcontracting Plan requirements in a bid protest, be mindful that some agencies may also have their own local rules in addition to the FAR 52.219-9. Making the argument that the goals are unrealistic will not get a favorable result. Agencies have the discretion to decide what is best when choosing their procurement strategies.  

  • Agencies have the discretion to decide what is best when choosing their procurement strategies.  

If there are no viable sources to meet the subcontracting plan requirements, then bidders should provide evidence to that effect in their proposals. If the source selection penalizes you, then you may have a viable challenge in a bid protest if the agency cannot provide conflicting facts.  See also Small Business Set Aside Bid Protests.

Government’s Obligation: FAR 19.705-2, titled “Determining the need for a subcontracting plan,” requires a contracting officer to ascertain, for each offeror, whether subcontracting possibilities exist before directing the offeror to submit a small business subcontracting plan. See also limitation on subcontracting.

In determining whether FAR subcontracting opportunities exist, FAR 19.705-2(b)(1), directs contracting officers to consider “relevant factors such as . . . [w]hether firms engaged in the business of furnishing the types of items to be acquired customarily contract for performance of part of the work or maintain sufficient in-house capability to perform the work.” 

  • Where a contracting officer has decided that a solicitation is for the award of a proposed contract which will provide subcontracting possibilities and is expected to exceed $650,000, FAR 19.708(b)(1) provides for the inclusion of FAR 52.219.9, Small Business Subcontracting Plan, in the solicitation.
  • This clause requires an apparently successful offeror to submit an acceptable small business subcontracting plan in order to receive a contract award.
  • The FAR provides that a contracting officer must determine–prior to the issuance of the solicitation–whether offerors are to submit a small business subcontracting plan.

Challenging the CO’s decision to include small business subcontracting plan requirements in the RFP almost never wins in a protest. Instead, you may want to look for vague terms, our show that there are no viable sources. Providing a copy of a SAM report with your proposal could help companies choosing to file a protest. See information about government contract bundling.

Tips When Challenging FAR 52.219-9 Small Business Subcontracting Plan Requirements

 Disputes arise when the agencies may not tell you that your small business subcontracting plan did not meet the agency’s expectation. First, bidders may want to see whether or not subcontracting plans were supposed to be evaluated. In negotiated procurements, the solicitation will provide guidance as to what weight, if any, is given to FAR 52.219-9 Subcontracting Plans.

  • Your goal when submitting a government proposal is to always see whether you can exceed the agency’s expectation as to the percentage for each subcategory.

Next, businesses who submit proposals for federal government contracts must understand that agencies are not required to discuss the contents of your Small Business Subcontracting Plan simply because it received a lower score than your competition.  More specifically, this issue comes up in meaningful discussions.  If your Small Business Subcontracting Plan was the tie breaker between your company and the awardee, then maybe there could be an argument when filing a bid protest.

If you are challenging Small Business Subcontracting Plan Requirements under FAR 52.219-9 in a bid protest to GAO or U.S. Court of Federal Claims, call our bid protest lawyers at 1-866-601-5518. FREE INITIAL CONSULTATION.

6 comments on “Challenging Small Business Subcontracting Plan Requirements FAR 52.219-9

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

You may use these HTML tags and attributes: <a href="" title=""> <abbr title=""> <acronym title=""> <b> <blockquote cite=""> <cite> <code> <del datetime=""> <em> <i> <q cite=""> <s> <strike> <strong>